The Safeguarding Policy in the Drawer
Most organisations I meet have a safeguarding policy. It is approved. It has a date on the cover. It sits in a folder on a shared drive, or in a drawer in the HR office, and it has not been opened since the day it was signed.
Then something happens.
A junior member of staff tells a colleague that a supervisor keeps asking her to stay behind after work. The colleague says she should be careful. A month later she resigns. Nobody writes anything down, because nobody knows what to write down or who to write it for. The policy exists. It did nothing.
That is the gap I work in, and it is wider than most leaders admit.
Why the policy fails
A policy fails in daily life for three reasons, and I see all three often.
Nobody knows who to tell. Ask five staff members, separately, who they would report a concern to. If you get five different answers, or five blank looks, the policy is not working. A reporting line that exists only on paper protects nobody.
The report goes to the wrong person. In many organisations, the route runs through the line manager, or through someone close to the leadership. When the concern is about that manager, or about a friend of the director, the complaint stops there. People know this. They stay quiet because they have worked out where the complaint ends up.
Nobody has ever tested it. A good system has been used and corrected. Many organisations have never walked through a single case from first report to final decision. The first time they try is a real case, with a real person in distress, and a team that is making it up as it goes.
What silence means
Some leaders tell me their organisation has had no safeguarding reports in years, and they say it with pride.
I hear something else. If a team of fifty has received no reports in three years, the likelier explanation is that people do not trust the process enough to use it. Concerns exist in every workplace. The question is whether they reach you or reach the car park.
Five checks you can run this week
You do not need a consultant to start. Do these five things and write down what you find.
- Ask five people, separately, who they would tell. Include a new starter and someone from the field or a junior role.
- Trace one complaint route. Follow it from the first person who receives it to the final decision. Mark every point where the person complained about, or their close colleague, could stop it.
- Check the last 24 months. How many concerns were raised, how many were recorded, and how many ended with a documented decision?
- Check training. When did each staff member last hear the policy explained, in person and in plain language, beyond the day they joined?
- Run a practice case. Give your leadership team a realistic scenario and ask them to handle it in 30 minutes using only the policy. See where they argue, hesitate or guess.
If you cannot answer these confidently, the policy is a document. It is not yet a system.
Where to start
Start with the gaps, and fix the reporting route first. Everything else depends on people believing that a concern will reach someone who will act on it.
Safeguarding is part of how an organisation runs, alongside its strategy, its leadership and its culture. When it works, people can do their jobs without fear, partners and funders can trust you, and leaders hear about problems while they are still small.
If your organisation is working through a safeguarding challenge, or you want an honest review of where you stand, let’s talk.